top of page

The Costly Gamble: Why Tenant Screening Shouldn't Be DIY



In the world of property management, the temptation to cut costs and handle tenant screening personally can be strong. After all, how hard can it be to assess a potential tenant? Unfortunately, for one landlord, the decision to go the do-it-yourself route turned into a nightmare that lasted months, leaving them with maintenance issues, an eviction saga, and the daunting task of finding a new tenant.


Picture this: a landlord, eager to save money and time, decides to handle tenant screening independently. The result? A series of unfortunate events that unfolded like a nightmare. The tenant, who seemed perfect on paper, turned out to be a nightmare in reality. Months of dealing with overdue rent, property damage, and finally, the lengthy eviction process, left the landlord reeling.


Maintenance issues piled up, expenses skyrocketed, and the property was left in shambles. The once-thriving rental turned into a costly headache. Now, faced with an empty property and financial losses, the landlord realized the importance of thorough tenant screening.


Here are some of the common pitfalls of skipping out a thorough tenant screening process:


1. Financial Stability: Without a proper check on a tenant's income and employment, landlords risk renting to someone who may struggle to meet rent obligations.

2. Rental History: Ignoring a potential tenant's rental history could mean welcoming a problematic tenant with a track record of property damage or lease violations.

3. Criminal Background: Failure to screen for criminal history might expose landlords to safety risks and potential legal issues.

4. Reference Checks: Skipping reference checks means missing valuable insights from previous landlords or employers, vital for predicting a tenant's behavior.

5. Creditworthiness: Neglecting credit checks may lead to leasing to someone with a poor financial track record, increasing the likelihood of missed payments.






Recognizing the pitfalls of DIY tenant screening, Umbrella has developed a comprehensive 7-step approach to ensure landlords find the perfect fit for their properties:


1. Application Review: A thorough analysis of the tenant's application provides an initial understanding of their background.

2. Credit Check: Assessing the tenant's credit history helps gauge financial responsibility and the likelihood of on-time rent payments.

3. Income Verification: Confirming employment and income details ensures the tenant has the means to meet financial obligations. We typically like to see a tenant's gross income is 2-3x the monthly rent.

4. Rental History Check: Reviewing past rental experiences helps identify potential red flags and predict future behavior. We go beyond looking at

5. Criminal Background Check: Ensuring tenant safety and legal compliance by examining criminal history.

6. Reference Checks: Contacting previous landlords and employers for insights into the tenant's reliability and behavior.

7. Personal Interview: A face-to-face or virtual meeting allows for a more personal assessment of the tenant.


The story of the ill-fated DIY landlord serves as a cautionary tale for property owners. Cutting corners on tenant screening can lead to financial losses, legal troubles, and significant stress. Umbrella's meticulous 7-step approach stands as a testament to the importance of a comprehensive screening process in ensuring a harmonious landlord-tenant relationship and safeguarding your investment. In the world of property management, knowledge is power, and a thorough tenant screening is the key to a successful, headache-free rental experience.




1 view0 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page